Please Use Search Functions Below
Main PageCoalitionCurrent InitiativesThe NCDD Online CommunityResourcesNews & Events2002 NCDD Conference
Egyptian Intellectual Encourages Dialogue

In an April 7 New York Times article, Susan Sachs writes of her fascinating interview with Ahmed Kamal Aboulmagd, one of Egypt?’s best-known intellectuals. Mr. Aboulmagd, who has spent over 20 years working on projects aimed at promoting dialogue between the Western, non-Muslim civilization and the Arab-Muslim world, talked about the Arab world?’s distress and distrust of American policies and actions. But he also emphasized the importance of dialogue during this difficult time. "I believe dialogue is needed now, so we should not give in to desperation, to loss of hope, to pessimism,?” he said. ?“Rather we should act actively and continue the path of dialogue and the path of understanding, simply because we cannot afford the other consequence." Click on ?“read more info?” below for the entire article, or search for it at

New York Times, April 7

Egyptian Intellectual Speaks Of the Arab World's Despair

CAIRO, April 6 ?— Early in the morning, while most of Cairo is asleep, Ahmed Kamal Aboulmagd watches the war on television and despairs over the path taken by the United States. Even in the gloom of 4 a.m., this is not a normal emotion for Mr. Aboulmagd, a sprightly man of 72 who has lived through more than his share of revolutions, wars and international crises, yet has maintained a marvelously sunny outlook.

"We should never lose hope," he remarked the other day from his 18th-floor law office overlooking the Nile, a room crammed with books and brightened with paintings of sailboats on calm waters. "Frustration is not an option."
But in truth, Mr. Aboulmagd admitted, he is just whistling in the dark. Never have America's Arab friends, he said, felt so estranged from the United States.

"People in Egypt and many parts of the Arab world used to love America, and now they have a sense of being betrayed, misunderstood, taken lightly," he said. "And when it comes to the central problem of the Middle East ?— the Arab-Israeli conflict ?— we feel that even a minimum of American even-handedness is missing."

Mr. Aboulmagd is one of Egypt's best-known intellectuals, a senior aide to former President Anwar el Sadat, consultant to the United Nations and ever-curious polymath whose interests range across the fields of Islamic jurisprudence, comparative religions, literature, history and commercial law.

Like many educated Egyptians of his generation, he is a man whose views on democracy and political values were shaped by reading the United States Constitution, the Federalist papers and the writings of Thomas Jefferson and Woodrow Wilson.

For him the United States was a "dream," a paragon of liberal values to be emulated by Arabs and Muslims seeking to have a voice in the modern world.
One of his daughters lived in the United States. Mr. Aboulmagd studied there, earning a master's degree in comparative law at the University of Michigan in 1959. He served as president of the administrative tribunal of the World Bank in Washington. And he has spent more than 20 years of his life working on projects aimed at promoting dialogue between the Western, non-Muslim civilization and the Arab-Muslim world.

Yet these days, in his opinion, something has gone terribly wrong.
"Under the present situation, I cannot think of defending the United States," said Mr. Aboulmagd, a small man with thinning white hair who juggles a constant stream of phone calls and invitations to speak about modernizing the Arab world.

"I would not be listened to," he added. "To most people in this area, the United States is the source of evil on planet earth. And whether we like it or not, it is the Bush administration that is to blame."

When speaking of President Bush and his administration, Mr. Aboulmagd uses words like narrow-minded, pathological, obstinate and simplistic. The war on Iraq, he said bluntly, is the act of a "weak person who wants to show toughness" and, quite frankly, seems "deranged."

Such language from a man of Mr. Aboulmagd's stature is a warning sign of the deep distress that has seized the Arab elite, those who preach moderation in the face of rising Islamic radicalism and embrace liberalism over the tired slogans of Arab nationalism.

Similar opinions can also be heard these days from wealthy Arab businessmen, university professors, senior government officials and Western-leaning political analysts ?— the people whose support could help advance the Bush administration's professed mission: to bring democracy to the Arab world.

Mr. Aboulmagd has a hand in just about every institution or board that counts in Egypt, including al Azhar, the authoritative institution of Sunni Muslim learning. He is consulted on inter-cultural dialogue by the United Nations, the Arab League and the European Union. He has taught law in universities in Egypt, Sudan and Kuwait.

He is the epitome of the Arab establishment. Sprinkled throughout his conversation are anecdotes about President Sadat and recollections of discussions with luminaries like the United Nations general secretary, Kofi Annan. He receives phone calls from Arab presidents and kings. His office is filled with mementos from trips around the world as a lecturer and consultant. An oversize Koran in a green leather case rests on a coffee table along with a rendition of the scales of justice in brass and alabaster.

He has devoted decades of his life and his writings to the cause of modernizing Islamic life and promoting understanding between Muslims and non-Muslims.
Now those efforts, Mr. Aboulmagd said, have been set back by President Bush's "exaggerated" response to the terror attacks of Sept. 11, a response he believes only encouraged mutual enmity and suspicion by painting Muslims and Arabs as potential enemies to be reformed or destroyed.

"I find what is happening to be a serious setback in the endeavors of noble people who have realized the commonalities among different civilizations and nations," he said.

The problem, he said, is that the war on Iraq is widely seen in the Arab world as an attack on all Arabs, meant to serve the interests of Israel with no compensating outreach to aggrieved Arabs.

While the 1991 Persian Gulf war, under Mr. Bush's father, was waged with the understanding that the United States would engage itself in the search for peace, he said, this war was launched without a parallel American effort to compel Israel to forge a genuine peace with the Palestinians.

"The United States has played a destructive role by giving direct or indirect green lights to the Israeli government to do what it pleases," Mr. Aboulmagd said. "This is ruining Israel's future in the area. And whatever, even if all the Arabs sign up, this is a truce, this is a ceasefire, this is not peace. It is not peace. If you want peace you must have genuine desire for peace."

If the Iraq war comes to be seen as an American war against Islam, he added, President Bush may be partly to blame. "He believes he was chosen by the Almighty to fulfill a Christian mission," Mr. Aboulmagd said. "Or at least he was made to believe that by the people around him."

Still, at the end of three hours of discussion, he returned to an optimistic viewpoint ?— a position that clearly fits his nature.

"Many people are talking about planet earth being no more a safe place for anyone, but I am optimistic," he said. "I believe dialogue is needed now, so we should not give in to desperation, to loss of hope, to pessimism. Rather we should act actively and continue the path of dialogue and the path of understanding, simply because we cannot afford the other consequence."

Added by Sandy on April 9, 2003 06:20 PM
Click here to return to the Main Page
Comments, Suggestions & Additions:

So quiet lately. Any more comment please.

Posted by: whois on August 22, 2003 10:48 PM
Post a Comment, Suggestion or Addition:


* An email address is required. For your protection, this comment system has an anti-spam device built into it.

** When posting a comment, please include additional information about yourself, especially your organization. ? For instructions on how to include a link in your comment, suggestion or addition, please click below.


This forum was created to provide dialogue & deliberation practitioners with the support, resources and ideas they need for organizing, facilitating and encouraging D&D during this time of war. Add your comments to existing postings, or send ideas for new postings to .


Resources on this Forum have been Converted
SCRC Post-War Discussion Materials
Please Use the Links on the Right


Background Info
????Links to Iraq Data
????Public Opinion on the War
????Analysis at
????Public Opinion on Protest & Patriotism
????Terrorism & Nonviolence
????Peace-Oriented Resources

D&D Guides on Iraq/Foreign Policy
????SCRC Post-War Discussion Materials

D&D Programs on Iraq
????Art Meets Dialogue in Richmond Event
????Online "Rotisserie" on the War
????Online Deliberation About the War
???? Brings People Together
????By the People: America in the World
????Discussion at
????DWCW Online Forum

Discussion & Exploration
????Resources on this Forum have been Converted
????Please Use the Links on the Right
????Feedback Needed about Iraq Dialogue
????Ideas/Thoughts About This Forum?

Encouraging Youth D&D
????ESR?’s Revised Guide for Parents & Educators
????Univ of Michigan Resources for Teachers
????PoliTalk to Host Online Student Conference
????United Youth Int?’l Fosters Online Dialogue
????YouthNOISE Helps Youth Communicate
????Global Kids Conference on War & Peace
????Best & Worst Things to Say to Kids

Opportunities & Ideas
????Conference on Muslim Peace-Building
????Articles Needed on Dialogue
????Blue Buttons Promote Dialogue

Others Encouraging D&D
????ACR Calls for Dialogue
????Egyptian Intellectual Encourages Dialogue

Tips and Resources for Facilitators
????Resources at Co-Intelligence Inst. Site
????U.S.-Iraqi Youth Dialogue Video
????PCP Dialogue Guide
????Study Circles Discussion Guide
????National Issues Forum Guide
????Overview of Conversation Café Model
????NCDD?’s List of D&D Organizations & Programs
????Introductory Facilitation Resources

Site MenuPress InfoHistoryContact UsGet InvolvedFrequently Asked Questions

Movable Type 2.63